2 min read

Auditing email campaigns

Tshedimoso Makhene Jan 4, 2025 8:43:09 PM

Editorial

Auditing email campaigns involves a review of email marketing strategies, content, performance metrics, and compliance with best practices and regulations. It's a strategy to improve performance and maintain compliance.

Why audit your email campaigns?

A study has shown that 53.3% of patients read 66–100% of emails from their physicians. This suggests that while email is important, not all emails are important. Auditing your email campaigns can ensure you effectively leverage this communication medium by identifying what works, optimizing performance, and maintaining compliance with industry regulations.

An email audit helps you:

Identify what works and what doesn’t.
Optimize content and design for better engagement.
Improve deliverability and reduce bounce rates.
Ensure compliance with regulations such as GDPR and CAN-SPAM.
Maximize ROI through data-driven insights.

Steps to audit your email campaigns

Define your objectives

Start by clarifying why you’re auditing your email campaigns. Are you looking to improve open rates, increase click-throughs, or boost conversions? Clear objectives guide the audit process and keep your analysis focused.

Review campaign goals

Are your campaigns aligned with overall marketing and business objectives?
Evaluate if your target audience segmentation is precise and effective.
Ensure that your campaigns address the specific needs and interests of your audience.

Analyze email content

Subject lines

Are they clear, engaging, and action-oriented?
Do they avoid spam-triggering words?

Body content

Is the message concise and relevant?
Does it provide value to the recipient?

Design and layout

Are the emails mobile-friendly?
Is the layout visually appealing and easy to navigate?

Call-to-action (CTA)

Are your CTAs compelling and strategically placed?
Do they align with the campaign’s purpose?

Evaluate list management

Review your email list-building strategies to ensure compliance with opt-in regulations.
Segment your audience based on behaviors, demographics, or preferences.
Identify and address inactive subscribers through re-engagement campaigns.

Check deliverability

Bounce rates: Categorize soft and hard bounces and update your lists accordingly.
Spam filters: Use tools to ensure your emails pass spam checks.
Sender reputation: Monitor your domain and IP reputation.

Assess automation workflows

Audit automated sequences like welcome emails, abandoned cart reminders, or follow-ups.
Check if the triggers, timing, and content are optimized to match user behavior.

Monitor metrics

Analyze key performance indicators (KPIs):

Open rate: Evaluate subject lines and sender names.
Click-through rate: Assess how well your content and CTAs drive engagement.
Conversion rate: Ensure your CTAs lead to meaningful actions.
Unsubscribes and complaints: Identify patterns that may indicate content or frequency issues.

Ensure compliance

Verify that your emails include clear opt-out options and company contact details.
Ensure compliance with GDPR, CAN-SPAM, and other relevant regulations.
Provide links to privacy policies when necessary.

Document findings

Create a detailed report summarizing strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement. Include actionable recommendations and set priorities based on potential impact.

Implement changes

Address quick wins such as improving subject lines or fixing broken links.
Plan and execute long-term improvements, like refining audience segmentation or adopting advanced personalization techniques.

Benefits of regular email audits

Conducting routine email audits:

Enhances user engagement by tailoring content to audience needs.
Reduces unsubscribe rates and improves customer loyalty.
Boosts ROI through targeted and effective campaigns.
Builds trust by ensuring regulatory compliance.

FAQs

How often should I audit my email campaigns?

You should generally audit your email campaigns quarterly, or more frequently if you run high-volume campaigns or notice declining performance metrics.